Saudi logic

Saudi human rights commisioner: "Religious particularities, as correctly viewed in Islam, supplement rather than detract from international human rights standards"

Zeid Al-Hussein's report to the United Nations Human Rights Council employs two standard pillars of apologetics for the condition of human rights in Islamic countries: The first is to label abuses of human rights as "individual" or "cultural" -- to do otherwise would be to admit specific elements of Islamic law are either not relevant to modern times, or simply flawed.The second is, in a related vein, to insist that Islamic law is just, but to acknowledge on some level that a staggering number of believers worldwide seem to keep getting it "wrong," generation after generation.

But these tired excuses set the stage for additional observations: First, zealous Muslims' efforts to obliterate heretical, pre-Islamic, and un-Islamic practices are well known and well documented. Even the untrained observer may find it odd how purportedly "un-Islamic" domestic violence and religious persecution keep falling through the cracks there (though the trained observer knows the role verses like Qur'an 4:34 and 9:29 actually play in perpetuating both).

Of course, if these "individual" and "cultural" practices are so odd and isolated, they should be pretty easy to stamp out. That is, unless Zeid al-Hussain is willing to admit they are widespread. And in that case, wouldn't he be calling Saudi Arabia a nation chock-full of hypocrites, sinners, and heretics up through the highest levels of royalty and clergy?

At least then there might be a greater sense of urgency than al-Hussain conveys below for improving conditions for human rights within the country. "Saudi Arabia defends Islam as complement to human rights," from Agence France-Presse, February 7:

GENEVA (AFP) — Saudi Arabia told the UN Human Rights Council on Friday that its status as an Islamic state should safeguard fundamental rights rather than fuel abuse, as it faced western calls for action to stop violations.

Zeid Al-Hussein, vice president of the country's three-year-old human rights commission, acknowledged there were violations in the country, often as a result of "individual practices" rooted in its tribal history.

But he insisted that Islamic law and practices should complement the legal standards the United Nations upholds.

"I wish to emphasize that -- and I weigh my words very carefully -- religious particularities, as correctly viewed in Islam, supplement rather than detract from international human rights standards," he told the Council.

"I am aware that, in most Islamic countries, individual practices do not always reflect the true essence of Islam and much remains to be done to ensure that human rights are promoted and protected," Hussein said.

Saudi Arabia's human rights record was being examined by the body's 47 member states under its first 'universal periodic review.'

"We acknowledge that there are some human rights violations attributable to individual practices," Hussein said.

And, uh, there are lots and lots of individuals in Saudi Arabia.

"Many of these violations fall within the context of domestic violence, to which confusion between the true Islamic Shari'a and customs and traditions is a contributing factor," he added.

Human rights groups such as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have been scathing of Saudi Arabia, highlighting its uneven application of executions -- 102 in 2008 and 153 in 2007 -- and strict Islamic policies.

Those include the way women are subject to a male guardian's permission to travel, work and marry.

They also complain of abuse of women, torture, widespread arbitrary arrest, indefinite detention without charge or trial and jailing of political activists in the Gulf nation.

Several countries, including Britain, Canada and Norway, recommended that Saudi Arabia abolish the family guardianship system and do more to prevent customs and traditions from harming women and children.

"While progress has been made, particularly in recent years, Saudi Arabia has more to do to ensure that its legal framework and domestic implementation meets international human rights standards," a British delegate told the Council. [...]

Hussein said the government was "constantly" trying to prevent domestic violence, control by husbands on their wives and children, pointed to a range of measures introduced over the past two years.

"In actual practice, the concept of guardianship, for example, often loses its connotation of responsibility and care, which are transformed into domination and coercion," he acknowledged. [...]

Funny how that keeps happening.

Despite guarantees for freedom of belief, non-Muslim religious worship could only be free within private homes in the Kingdom, Hussein said, largely due to the "sensitivities" that arose with its status as host to Islam's holiest shrines at Mecca and Medina.

"There is no point in discussing this issue from the standpoint of positive man-made law, since religious belief stems from the heart and not from rational proof," he explained.

"This our belief, which we expect others to respect and not contest, in the same way as we respect and do not contest their beliefs," he added.

Except once they're under sharia law -- like in Saudi Arabia. Then all bets are off.

Thanks Dhimmi Watch