Introduction
Both International Solidarity Movement (ISM) and Israel Committee Against House Demolitions (ICAHD) are radical NGOs whose agenda includes demonizing Israel as an ‘apartheid’ state and questioning the very existence of a Jewish state itself. Their plan to ‘break the Gaza blockade’ is a PR stunt designed to embarrass Israel and to promote their extreme ideas. ISM planned exactly the same event last year to ‘free Gaza’ but in the end it was cancelled, due to ‘funding, logistics, weather and other factors’. There is a chance that this year’s event will also fail to take place. Should this event actually happen, we hope that serious journalists will recognize it as nothing more than an elaborate publicity stunt and show minimal interest. However, should it attract media attention, the following points are useful to illustrate that far from being genuine humanitarian organizations, both ISM and ICAHD are extreme and irresponsible politicized groups:
International Solidarity Movement (ISM)
· ISM describes itself as “a Palestinian-led movement committed to resisting the Israeli occupation of Palestinian land using nonviolent, direct-action methods and principles”. Although ISM does not have a hierarchy with recognized leaders, it is a highly political organization.
· Although ISM claims to engage in ‘non violent’ action, acting as ‘protection’ for Palestinians, they encourage activists to take ‘direct action’, which often places them in danger, directly confronting the IDF.
· ISM has been responsible for endangering the safety of many foreign nationals, including placing both American citizen Rachel Corrie and UK citizen Tom Hurndall, in mortal danger. Both were killed by the IDF while participating in ISM activities.
· ISM regularly engages in direct confrontation with the IDF, irresponsibly endangering the lives of Palestinians and foreign activists. Most recently, they have been involved in the violent protests against the security barrier at Ni’lin.
· ISM attempted to help terrorists taking refuge in the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem in 2002
· In 2003, ISM was used as a cover by terrorists, originating from UK, who attacked the Mike’s Place bar in Tel Aviv, murdering three people.
Israel Committee Against House Demolitions (ICAHD)
· ICAHD also describes itself as a ‘non violent’, ‘direct action’ group. They describe themselves as having been “originally established to oppose and resist Israeli demolition of Palestinian houses in the Occupied Territories…we expanded our resistance activities to other areas - land expropriation, settlement expansion, by-pass road construction, policies of ‘closure’ and ‘separation,’ the wholesale uprooting of fruit and olive trees and more”.
· In reality, ICAHD brutally manipulates the language of human rights to promote a radical political agenda.
· Although ICAHD receives significant funds from EU and the Spanish government, they consistently refer to Israel as an ‘apartheid’ state and supports boycotts of Israel.
· Jeff Halper, ICAHD’s Director rejects the 2 state solution which would mean the end of Israel as a Jewish state. Halper said in a paper given at the "United Nations International Conference on Civil Society in Support of the Palestinian People" in New York in September, 2003, that "the stage is thus set for the next phase of the struggle for a just resolution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict: an international campaign for a single state."
· Halper regularly speaks as the "Israeli" or "Jewish" presence at Sabeel Conference tours in the USA. Led by Naim Ateek, Sabeel is a Palestinian Christian NGO that leads Church divestment campaigns. Halper promotes his mantra of a "matrix of control" but makes unsubstantiated claims: at the United Nations Latin America and Caribbean Meeting on the Question of Palestine in Caracas on 13 December 2005, Halper claimed that “Ninety-five percent of the cases of house demolitions had nothing to do with security,” but provided no source or evidence.
Useful Media Messages
· Both ISM and ICAHD are radical politicized groups, not genuine humanitarian organizations.
· ISM in particular has a record of placing foreign nationals in unnecessary danger, sometimes resulting in their death. This latest stunt is another example of irresponsibly endangering the safety of civilians in order to promote their extreme agenda.
· ISM and ICAHD are clearly more concerned with self-promotion than welfare. There can be no other explanation for spending a huge amount of money on sailing two ships from Cyprus (last year’s event would have cost at least an estimated $300,000) rather than sending aid to Gaza through the correct Israeli channels.
7 comments:
Dear Don Morris,
I wonder if you have ever been to the occupied Palestinian territories? I wonder if you have ever participated in any nonviolent actions? I wonder if you have ever studied the principles and the methods of nonviolence?
If you would read works by Martin Luther King, Jr. or Mahatma Gandhi, you would find that the very idea of nonviolent resistance is to directly confront the oppressive authority. Whether you agree with the perception that the IDF is an instrument of oppression or not, the fact that ISM claims to conduct nonviolence is very much aligned with the methods that "they encourage activists to take ‘direct action’, which often places them in danger, directly confronting the IDF."
Also, ISM does in no way trick its volunteers. They are very well aware of the risk of confronting the IDF, but have all made an informed decision that fighting for justice and for the rights of other people is worth it.
I have lived and worked in the West Bank for 15 months - as an ISM volunteer and as a university teacher, and I have often been struck by the fact that more strongly a person criticizes or demonizes the Palestinian people, the more ignorant they are of their history and their experience.
I cannot remember having met one stout supporter Israeli occupation of the West Bank, the siege of Gaza, the building of the Separation Wall on Palestinian land inside the West Bank and/or the continued settlement expansion, who has made the effort to go to Gaza or the West Bank to learn first hand about life under Israeli military occupation. How can you claim to know what is right and wrong, when you have never witnessed the reality on the ground; when you have never sought to understand the experience of the people you are opposing, criticizing or demonizing?
Trust me, seeing for yourself is not as dangerous and difficult as it might seem. In fact, I have often said that truth is just a plane ticket away. Once you are in Ben Gurion airport in Tel Aviv, all you need to do is to take a bus to Jerusalem, find your way to the Damascus Gate and from there jump a bus to the Kalandia Check Point. From here, you can board a public, Palestinian taxi - called a service - to any Palestinian city, town or village in the West Bank. I guarantee, if you are friendly and positive towards the people you meet, you will be as safe there as in downtown San Francisco.
If you want to have any kind of integrity as a supporter of Israel's policies towards the Palestinian people and the continued occupation of the West Bank, the least you can do is to commit a thousand dollars and one week’s vacation to learning about the Palestinian perspective.
Yours Sincerely,
Lasse Jeppesen Schmidt,
atturde@yahhoo.com
Interesting that you have decided that unless you have been to a location you cannot possibly understand or even "know" about a group, event, circumstance. Further you postulate that someone who has not made the "commitment" to do so, is not worthy of being listened to-I suspect that the only credible folks are people like you? Of course you are in danger, you purposefully place yourselves in that position, and your point is...?
I find additionally interesting one article, by the way I am not the author that"dares" criticize your organization can draw such wrath.
Having written this, know that I live in Israel-yes, I have been to Judea and Samaria. What you do not know is my background, my experience with Palestinians, what I have done with Israeli-Arabs-you know nothing at all and yet jump to conclusions. You make no mention of the impact the Palestinian actions have had on Israelis, Israeli-Arabs, children, innocent children. I know the region's history, I have been part of it in a small way-as a university teacher do you practice inquiry or indoctrination? Why tell me you are such a person unless you feel a need to be credible-when someone does this I have come to realize over the years I am dealing with often a passive-aggressive personality or ...
all the best,
doc
Re: "ISM regularly engages in direct confrontation with the IDF, irresponsibly endangering the lives of Palestinians and foreign activists."
The WWII Underground movement regularly engaged in direct confrontation with the Nazis using violent methods, endangering the lives of civilians and resistance members in the process. In concert with the rest of the world, presumably, this is not viewed by the writer as an example of irresponsible endangerment due to the need to confront a vicious occupation. There are no benevolent occupations. They are all acts of repression against a native population. That is what the ISM is fighting against in Palestine, with non-violent means. And you blame them for the deaths perpetrated by the 60-year occupiers. For shame.
I appreciate your articulation of points served. Well done. We stand on opposite sides of this argument-you call us occupiers, I understand and nothing I can write will change that position. Again, you avoid recognizing or even acknowledging the Palestinian horrific acts of violence against Israel. contrary to your final remark, I than our IDF for protecting us against the terrorism served up regularly by the people you defend. Th ISM is used as a tool in the terrorists' arsenal-you are complicit with their actions. Yet you shame me? All the more the pity-doc
My reference to the acts of violence by the WWII Resistance hardly denies “the Palestinian horrific acts of violence against Israel”. On the contrary, it recognises the inevitable consequences of occupation and repression. There is no need or desire to defend terrorists or their acts, only a need and desire to understand where they come from if we want to effectively come to terms with them. The IDF is a tool of suppression. Suppression works in the short term and invariably fails in the long run. Understanding and coming to terms with what terrorists really want – not what corrupt or ignorant interests would have us believe – is the only long-term answer. Statements that “they hate our way of life” or “they want to drive us into the sea” are just as ludicrous as stating that the terrorist Irgun and Stern gangs were examples of evil Jewish cabals who were out to destroy the goyim.
Saying that a non-violent group working for change like the ISM is “a tool in the terrorists' arsenal” smacks of McCarthy-era labelling of liberals as “Communist dupes” because they advocated some of the same things. The ISM does not support acts of terrorism whilst working to end the occupation. Liberals did not support Stalinist terrorism whilst working for the same social justice programs as communists.
Occupiers, of course, never perceive their actions to be an occupation. The evidence that Israel is maintaining a 60-year occupation of Palestine is overwhelming.
dear freind,
iam going to talk about ong thing which is Rachael corry, in your article you are saying that this palestinian movment put her into danger and for this reason she died, but you are not telling the whole story. if you are wondering or still dont know how rachael died then its a good opportunity to me to inform you that it died under an israeli boldozer (track) that was destroying and demoloting a palestinian neighberhood in the west bank which is recognized as an occupied land bu israel, as the United nations said. so if we need to judge anyone for the killing of this poor young women Rachael then is pretty obvious that the israeli army with all the equipment that he have and the guns and everything he got for destroying which in fact the united states of america is paying for it.. all of this reasons caused the death of rachael ...
Thank you also for reading my blog-amazing how posting this story has created such a response. I cannot take credit for writing it however. Yes, I am all too familiar with the RC story-I live in Israel and was present the day the event occurred. This story has exhausted itself except when individuals wish to use it as propaganda-of course in a democracy you have such rights unlike some territories or countries. The event research does indeed frame it in a manner that does not support your contention.
doc
Post a Comment