Sultan Knish
Putin's little fingers in the Ukraine, Cuban agents in Venezuela and the
Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt all remind us how uniquely vulnerable
democracy is totalitarianism. In the United States, cities aren't
burning and streets aren't filling up with bloodied bodies, but the
government of phone and pen also shows us that we are always one
election away from losing our freedom.
When
a political system becomes polarized between the forces of freedom and
the forces of totalitarianism, then the forces of freedom have to win
every single election. Meanwhile the totalitarians only have to win one
election and then spend the rest of time reconstructing civic
institutions, mobilizing thugs and making it structurally impossible for
the other side to compete.
Even if the other side occasionally
wins elections, the totalitarian process continues chugging along
because the totalitarian side follows no rules while holding its
opponents to above and beyond the letter of the law. The law constrains
the ability of the law-abiding party to undo the work of the
totalitarian party, but not the ability of the totalitarian party to
pursue its agenda and undo the work of its opponents.
When one side is on a long march through the institutions while the other seeks consensus, the long marchers will win.
A democratic political system in which a leading political faction is totalitarian cannot endure.
We
understand the practical lessons of that in Egypt, but less so in the
United States. A political process that included the Muslim Brotherhood
could not continue. Everyone except Obama Inc. prattling on about
inclusive politics understood that. The rightfully elected status of
Morsi did not matter. What did matter was that the Muslim Brotherhood
could not and would not work together with anyone. It did not want an
open political process, it wanted absolute power.
If the
Democratic Party continues to function as a radical leftist party,
abiding by no laws, imposing radical change unilaterally, and using its
media to cover for its corruption and political sins, the United States
will face a Venezuelan or Egyptian scenario.
The United States is
a fairly civilized place. Its people, despite the recession, are doing
fairly well. It may not seem like that when we look at the unemployment
rates, but unlike the Egyptians, we can afford bread and unlike the
Venezuelans, our stores still have milk and toilet paper. There are
still enough job prospects out there, that people haven't given up. At
least not all of them.
That's why the Tea Party, America's Orange
Revolution or Arab Spring, was fairly muted by comparison. Its
participants were older, educated and prosperous. If they actually were
the illiterate violent armed rabble that the left has done its best to
portray them as, the scenes in Cairo and Caracas would be replaying
themselves in the United States.
The Tea Party was a political
protest on the right by the small businessman and the established
professional. It was and is an effort by a threatened middle class to
salvage its position that for all its moments of anger lacked the
violent desperation that we see in Venezuela. But the differences lie in
political culture and desperation. The political culture has been
polarized and degraded to its lowest points. The rising left is angrier
and more militant than ever and the right is coming to feel that the
political process is useless and its gatekeepers are biased against
them.
Combine that perception with more economic hammer blows
against the middle class by the redistributionists, add a sense of
hopelessness and contrast that with growing arrogance by the powers of
the left and things will get very ugly.
America's Two Party
system has worked because both parties, for the most part, were not
absolutists. The exceptions, like FDR, did a great deal of damage, but
their sway was limited. What has changed is the level of mobilization,
coordination and integration on the left. Social institutions, major
corporations, the media, unions, non-profits and the educational system
have been knitted together into a totalitarian entity with an agenda.
This state of affairs transcends democracy and cannot be remedied by
democratic elections.
Even
if Republicans were to win the White House and dominate the House and
the Senate, they would still face a totalitarian entity whose judges
would make laws, whose media would subvert democracy, whose educational
institutions and entertainment industry would reprogram the people and
whose bureaucracy would undermine any decision that it did not like.
Every
area of life is being politicized and this politicization did not take
place as a result of elections and cannot be stopped with mere
elections. The politicization of everything is the indication of a
totalitarian movement at work. To politicize a thing is to claim
ownership over it. Universal politicization means absolute power for the
politicizers.
Political conflicts with totalitarians are a
cultural war. The totalitarians employ every cultural, political and
economic element that they can against their enemies. They follow only
those laws that are convenient meanwhile they multiply laws to pin down
their opponents. They define entire elements of the population that they
hope to dismpower or destroy, whether it's the Copts in Egypt or the
private sector middle class in the United States, and execute their
plans.
Resisting totalitarians cannot simply be an electoral
activity. In a system of democratic political elections, the ballot box
becomes the weakest element in defying totalitarians who can always find
ways to buy elections, steal elections or convince the people that if
they don't vote the wrong way then the sky will fall and the oceans will
rise. Those who follow no laws have many options; those who follow them
have only a few.
The electoral wars matter, but the
totalitarians have to be fought for control of every institutions and
defied at every point of control. It's not enough to win an election,
their ideas have to be discredited. It's not enough to swap out
politicians when entire institutions have to be swapped out. The core
solution isn't political; it's personal. It's in how we live.
Totalitarians
politicize everything. And that really means everything from the food
you eat to the books you watch to the way you heat your home and drive
to work. Individually we can all make choices that neutralize the
politicization even in matters as simple as choosing the movies we watch
or leaving products with environmentalist tripe on the packaging on the
shelf. Local battles are also bigger battles as Common Core
demonstrates. And the synagogue or church you attend is also a statement
of support for the left or a rejection of the left.
The first
stage of a culture war is to cease supporting the enemy. The second
stage is to push back by building up your institutions that make your
way of life possible. The third stage is to use those institutions
against the enemy.
Anyone
can engage in the first stage of the culture war by making more
conservative choices. The second stage requires a bit more planning, but
it's a product of the first stage. And when the institutions of the
second stage become powerful enough and successful enough, then the
third stage becomes possible.
Elections alone will not defeat the
left. Totalitarian movements aren't defeated at the voting booth, but
in the hearts of men and women. And if their grip on power continues,
then the scenes of violence and terror that we see on the evening news
will come to our streets and cities.
No comments:
Post a Comment